AI can already hold long conversations, ask questions, explain symptoms and guide people through exercises. Specially developed generative AI systems are now also being studied as therapeutic tools, and the first results are interesting. This means the question is no longer only science fiction: Can AI perform parts of therapy? Yes, probably. But that is different from being able to replace a therapist.
Some parts of psychotherapy are relatively structured. Psychoeducation, recording thoughts and feelings, exercises and homework can be digitised to some extent. A chatbot may be available at three in the morning, help a person put difficult experiences into words or practise an upcoming conversation. For some people this may be the first step towards seeking professional help.
But a conversation that feels empathetic is not automatically therapy. AI produces language from patterns in data; it has no lived experience, body or professional responsibility of its own. A therapist also assesses pauses, tone of voice, changes over time, medication, physical illness, social circumstances and risk. And the therapist must be able to recognise when conversation alone is no longer enough and other or more intensive help is needed.
A new challenge also arises when AI is no longer experienced as a tool but as a relationship. A person with social anxiety may initially benefit greatly from talking with AI because it feels easier and less demanding than contact with other people. But if the digital relationship gradually replaces the exposure to human contact that the person actually needs, the help may end up perpetuating avoidance. The relevant question is therefore not just whether the conversation feels good, but whether it helps the person move forward in life.
AI could play an important role in psychotherapy by supporting psychoeducation, preparation, exercises and follow-up. It can also help therapists work more efficiently. The question for the future may therefore be not whether AI will replace therapists, but whether therapists who use AI wisely will replace those who do not. The human relationship, judgement and accountability must nevertheless remain at the heart of therapy.
Further reading
- Heinz MV, Mackin DM, Trudeau BM, et al. Randomized Trial of a Generative AI Chatbot for Mental Health Treatment. NEJM AI. 2025.
- Zhang Q, Zhang R, Xiong Y, et al. Generative AI Mental Health Chatbots as Therapeutic Tools. JMIR. 2025.
- Flückiger C, Del Re AC, Wampold BE, Horvath AO. The Alliance in Adult Psychotherapy. 2018.