Disposition – The Same Screen Affects Us Differently

The same film, comment or message does not affect everyone in the same way. The effect depends, among other things, on age, personality, self-esteem, mental state and individual circumstances.

A person with social anxiety may benefit greatly from a safe online community and perhaps take a first step towards connecting with others. But if online contact becomes a way to avoid all face-to-face encounters, it may also perpetuate anxiety [1].

Someone with depression or low self-esteem may be more sensitive to missing likes, criticism or images of others’ seemingly perfect lives. By contrast, an outgoing person may use the same platforms to maintain friendships and build new connections [1].

Age matters too. Young people are often more sensitive to their peers’ judgement, exclusion and social comparison. Older people, meanwhile, may benefit greatly from digital conversations with family and friends and thereby feel less lonely [2].

Søren Kierkegaard emphasised ‘the individual’—the concrete human being who must not simply disappear into the crowd [3]. This idea is highly relevant to digital mental health. We cannot understand someone’s digital life by counting minutes alone. We must ask what technology means to that particular person.

We should therefore not treat everyone alike. A young person with body-image insecurity may need help cleaning up their feed. An older person living alone may benefit from more digital contact. A person with ADHD may find digital reminders useful while also being easily distracted by constant sounds and notifications.

Good guidance does not begin with a universal rule. It begins with curiosity: What helps you? What makes you anxious? What do you lose control over? And what brings you connection, knowledge or enjoyment?

References


  1. Gupta L, Bharti D, Singhal S. Not all clicks are equal: digital dose, content, and user disposition in mental health. Academia Mental Health and Well-Being. 2026;3(1). doi:10.20935/MHealthWellB8208.

  2. Cotten SR, Schuster AM, Seifert A. Social media use and well-being among older adults. Current Opinion in Psychology. 2022;45:101293. doi:10.1016/j.copsyc.2021.12.005.

  3. Cappelørn NJ. Den enkelte. Lex – Danmarks Nationalleksikon. Om Søren Kierkegaards begreb om det enkelte menneske.